The short answer: jalapeno reads hotter on the label
If you are choosing between the two Totally Nuts bottles based on heat, the Creamy Jalapeno is the one whose name and description point to a jalapeno kick. Smokeshow Totally Nuts is described as bold and nutty, with a rich, savory flavor and a satisfying crunch, but the listing does not name a pepper or a heat level.
That does not prove Smokeshow is mild. It means the supplied information gives you a clear heat cue for Creamy Jalapeno and no equivalent cue for Smokeshow. If heat is your deciding factor, start with the jalapeno bottle and treat Smokeshow as the nut-forward option to try when you want savory depth rather than a named pepper flavor.
What each listing actually says about flavor
Both are 9-ounce Bitchin' Sauce bottles in the Totally Nuts line, so the comparison comes down to the flavor language in each listing rather than size or format.
- Creamy Jalapeno Totally Nuts: Described as creamy with a jalapeno kick, and suggested for sandwiches, wraps, or as a dip. The heat cue is explicit; the intensity is not quantified.
- Smokeshow Totally Nuts: Described as bold, nutty, rich, and savory with a satisfying crunch, and suggested for dipping, spreading, or drizzling. No pepper or heat level is named.
Confirmed details behind the heat comparison
- Creamy Jalapeno Totally Nuts - 9oz: Creamy Jalapeno Totally Nuts is described as bringing a creamy texture with a jalapeno kick. This is the clearest heat signal in either listing, which makes it the safer first pick if you want a pepper-forward sauce.

Creamy Jalapeno Totally Nuts - 9oz - Smokeshow Totally Nuts - 9oz: Smokeshow Totally Nuts is described as having a bold, nutty twist with a rich, savory flavor and a satisfying crunch. The description emphasizes nutty and savory notes rather than pepper heat, so it suits readers prioritizing flavor depth over spice.

Smokeshow Totally Nuts - 9oz
Where the heat comparison runs out of evidence
Neither listing states a Scoville rating, a mild-to-hot scale, or a pepper quantity. The Creamy Jalapeno listing confirms jalapeno flavor but does not say how much heat that delivers, and the Smokeshow listing does not confirm whether any pepper is used at all.
That means you cannot rank these two by measured heat from the supplied information. You can only rank them by how clearly each listing signals heat: Creamy Jalapeno names a pepper, Smokeshow does not. If you need a guaranteed heat level, check the bottle label or contact the store before buying rather than assuming one is hotter than the other.
How to choose based on how you will use the bottle
- You want a dip with a pepper kick: Creamy Jalapeno is the listing that explicitly mentions jalapeno and suggests use as a dip, so it fits a chips-and-veggies setup where you want that flavor called out.
- You want a savory, nutty spread or drizzle: Smokeshow's rich, savory, nut-forward description suits spreading on sandwiches or drizzling over dishes where you want depth rather than a named pepper.
- You are serving a group with mixed heat tolerance: Offer both bottles side by side and label them. The jalapeno bottle carries the heat cue; Smokeshow gives guests a nutty alternative without a stated pepper flavor.
- You only want one bottle in the fridge: Pick Creamy Jalapeno if you specifically want jalapeno flavor, or Smokeshow if you want the nuttier, savory profile. Both are 9 ounces, so the choice is flavor, not quantity.
What to check on the label before you commit
The supplied listings do not include ingredient lists, allergen statements, storage instructions, or a stated shelf life for either bottle. If you are avoiding specific ingredients or need to know how to store an opened bottle, read the physical label or ask the store before purchasing.
The listings also do not confirm whether either sauce is intended to be refrigerated after opening. Treat that as an open question rather than assuming either way.



